史上最牛论文

source http://www.shamoxia.com/html/y2011/2812.html

上古神话传说中,Einstein的大作“论动体的电动力学”只有短短数页,并且没有参考文献,被奉为神文。没想到69年后,Einstein被超越了,出现了一篇空白论文。更神奇的是此空白论文竟被引用了12次。

此文发表在《应用行为分析杂志》1974年第7卷497页上。除了标题(“一例‘写作瓶颈’的失败自疗”—The Unsuccessful Self-treatment of a Case of “Writer’s Block”),作者名(Dennis Upper), 及隶属机构(Veterans Administration Hospital, Brockton, Massachusetts)之外,一片空白。无一词一句,无一篇引用文献。大半页空白下,除了编辑加注的“于1973年10月25日收到,无修改即发 表”和例行声明及通讯作者地址外,就是此文画龙点睛的传奇评论了。

这位匿名审稿人是这么说的: “我仔仔细细地审阅了这篇论文,连柠檬汁和X 射线都用上了,也没找到实验设计或写作风格上的任何瑕疵。我建议,此文无需修改,直接发表。很明显,这绝对是我读过的最为简明扼要的论文,而它又包含了足 够的细节使得其他研究人员能够轻而易举地重复阿普尔博士的失败结果。跟你们编辑扔给我的其他那些又臭又长的论文比起来,审阅这篇论文真是美好的享受。再说 了,我们肯定能在杂志里找到发表这篇论文的地方—比如一张空白页的边缘?”

此作者绝对不是什么业余混混,履历相当专业:

http://www.linkedin.com/profile/view?id=4368992&authType=name&authToken=dbbF&pvs=pp&trk=ppro_viewmore

DennisUpper

Vice President of Client Services at New England Center for Homeless Veterans
Greater Boston AreaMental Health Care

Current • Chief Program Officer at hopeFound
Past • Private Practice; Director at Woburn Outpatient Clinic
• Director of Outpatient & Community Support Services at Center for Mental Health & Retardation Services
• Director of Clinical Development at May Behavioral Health

• Executive Director of Behavioral Medicine at Neponset Valley Health System
• Director of Outpatient Services at Brookside Hospital/Northeast Psychiatric Associates
• Director of Substance Abuse Treatment at Lahey Clinic Medical Center
• Coordinator of Behavior Therapy Unit at Brockton VA Medical Center

Education

• Case Western Reserve University
• University of Cincinnati
• Yale University

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

生活在西班牙

自己动手丰衣足食

BlueAsteroid

Just another WordPress.com site

Jing's Blog

Just another WordPress.com site

Start from here......

我的心情魔方

天才遠私廚

希望能做一個分享各種資訊的好地方

语义噪声

西瓜大丸子汤的博客

笑对人生,傲立寰宇

Just another WordPress.com site

Where On Earth Is Waldo?

A Project By Melanie Coles

the Serious Computer Vision Blog

A blog about computer vision and serious stuff

Cauthy's Blog

paper review...

Cornell Computer Vision Seminar Blog

Blog for CS 7670 - Special Topics in Computer Vision

datarazzi

Life through nerd-colored glasses

Luciana Haill

Brainwaves Augmenting Consciousness

槑烎

1,2,∞

Dr Paul Tennent

and the university of nottingham

turn off the lights, please

A bunch of random, thinned and stateless thoughts around the Web

%d bloggers like this: